As PE Roll-Ups Fade, How to Command a Premium Exit in 2026
Insurance M&A volume dropped to a seven-year low of 646 deals in 2026, but agencies with 90%+ retention and low owner dependence command 10x-13x EBITDA.
Speed to lead, AI search, CRM hygiene, and the systems that help insurance agencies win more policies.
Insurance M&A volume dropped to a seven-year low of 646 deals in 2026, but agencies with 90%+ retention and low owner dependence command 10x-13x EBITDA.
ManhattanLife closed its second New York charter in March 2026, per Insurance Business, giving agencies more placement flexibility in a tightly held market.
LIMRA forecasts 2% to 6% premium growth in 2026, down from 10% in 2025, so agency teams win share by sharpening lead conversion, not buying more volume.
BaFin's 2026 AI oversight framework allows fines up to €15 million as 23+ U.S. states adopt NAIC AI rules, reshaping downline AI governance for IMOs in 2026.
OPTIS Partners logged only 292 H1 2026 agency deals, down 15%; IMOs with documented, clean tech stacks can defend valuation multiples 15-20% higher.
64% of agencies now run AI in a core workflow, and IMOs bundling a shared AI front office into agent contracts are pulling ahead in 2026 downline recruiting.