Page 11 of 12.
Insurance agency referral leads close at 30 to 60 percent versus 8 to 15 percent for web leads, per 2026 benchmarks on close rates and speed to lead.
A 2026 benchmark on AI citation share for insurance and local-service queries: how selective ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini are, why ~78% of independent operators have near-zero citation share, and the owned-source and earned-media levers that move it.
2026 data: top-quartile agencies average 8-minute lead response and close 41% of leads; bottom-quartile manual shops average 11.8 hours and close 12%.
A 2026 Kadence benchmark finds 47% of insurance inquiries arrive after hours, peaking at 5 to 8 PM, with 85% of missed callers never calling back.
A traceable ROI breakdown for AI receptionists at insurance agencies: cost per call, seat-replacement savings, published payback windows, and a recovered-premium formula you can run on your own book.
New 2026 data: insurance agencies average 9.1-hour lead response times while 63.5% of companies never reply at all, per GreetNow and RevenueHero research.